Skip to main content
Free PDF · Scorecard

Build vs Buy Scorecard

Sort your requirements, cost both options over five years and record the decision, so it rests on your own figures.

What You Get

The Build vs Buy Scorecard is a three-page PDF for a business that needs new software and has to choose between a product it can subscribe to and a system built for it. It turns the questions in our guide on how to evaluate build vs buy into a sheet you fill in, so the answer comes from your requirements and your costs rather than from whichever option sounds simpler.

What Is Inside

  • A requirements sort: core, important or nice to have, and standard or specific to your business
  • Seven questions for the product you would buy, from feature gaps to data export and what happens if the vendor is sold
  • Six questions for a custom build, including who owns the code at the end
  • A five-year cost worksheet for both options that counts your team’s time spent on workarounds
  • Five strategic fit questions on control, speed and dependence on one vendor
  • A decision box with a review date

Who This Is For

Owners, directors and managers about to commit to a CRM, a client portal, an operations system or similar, who want to see the long-run cost of each route before they sign. No technical background is needed. If you already know you are building, the Software Requirements Template is the better place to start.

How to Use This

Fill in the requirements first, with the people who will use the system. The number of core requirements that are specific to your business tells you a lot about how well any product will fit. Then score the product you like best and get a written estimate for a build, and put both into the five-year worksheet. The App & Software Cost Checklist lists the build and running costs to include on the build side.

Why We Made This

People often bring us a build vs buy question after they have already paid for a product that covers most of what they need, and the gaps have turned into spreadsheets beside it. Sometimes building is the answer. Often it is a better-chosen product. The scorecard works either way, and if you want someone to go through it with you, that is what our technical consulting is for.

Get the Scorecard

Fill in the short form and the PDF opens straight away. We email you the link too. Everything else we have published is in the resource library.

Portrait of Alexander De Sousa, founder of Digital Royalty
Founder-led
“I’ve put everything I know into how this company works — the standards, the method, the care on every project. It runs through the whole team, and I hold us all to it.”

Alexander De Sousa · Founder LinkedIn

Featured on BBC Radio Solent

Get started

Tell us what you need

A few quick questions, then a straight answer from a real person — usually within a few hours.

What happens next

  1. 1 We reply A real person reads your answers and gets back to you, usually within a few hours.
  2. 2 Questions or a short call If anything isn't clear, we ask by email or book a short call. Before any call we audit your website and make the quick fixes it finds, free.
  3. 3 Your fixed quote A clear, fixed price in writing, within 48 hours of any call. There is no obligation to go ahead.

Tell us what you're working on

Whether it's a new site, a platform, or a process that shouldn't be manual any more — we'll tell you honestly if we can help.