Skip to main content

Subscriptions vs Custom Build Calculator

This calculator compares two ways of paying for the same software: keep renting the subscriptions you have, or replace them with a system built for you and pay for its upkeep. You enter the monthly bill, a build quote and what owning would cost to run. It shows the total each way over the years you choose, and the month the build catches up with the subscriptions, if it ever does. There is no sign-up and nothing you type is sent anywhere. It sits with our other free tools.

It is for an owner or operations lead who keeps paying a rising bill for a stack of tools and wants to know whether owning would be cheaper. Sometimes the honest answer is that renting is, and the calculator will say so.

What it asks for

Subscriptions the build would replace. The monthly total for the tools a custom system would take over. Include the per-seat add-ons and the tools that only exist to connect the others, such as Zapier or Make, because a single owned system usually removes those too.

Subscriptions you’d keep anyway. Most businesses keep some rented software next to a build, such as email, the accounts package or the phone system. This figure only counts on the owning side, so it stops the comparison flattering the build.

One-off build quote. The price of building the replacement. Use a real quote if you have one.

Hosting, upkeep and support each month. What it costs to keep the owned system running. A vendor quietly covers security updates, backups and fixes when a connected system changes. Once you own the software, someone you pay does that, so this figure has to include it. Set it too low and owning looks better than it is.

Enter every price with VAT or every price without it. Mixing the two skews the result.

The assumptions it adds

Two figures are not yours, so the calculator shows them as ranges you can change. Both carry a placeholder label.

The first is how much the subscription bill rises each year. It starts at 5% to 20%. That covers list-price rises plus the seats, contacts or usage you add as the business grows. It is our starting guess, not a published benchmark. Your own renewal letters and last year’s invoices are better evidence, and if the team and the prices won’t change, put 0 in both boxes. The subscriptions you keep rise at the same rate.

The second is a contingency on the build quote, starting at 0% to 25%. It leaves room for changes you ask for once you see the system working. If you have a fixed-price quote you trust, set both to 0.

The cautious case pairs the slower rise with the bigger contingency, which favours renting. The best case does the opposite and the expected case takes the middle of both ranges. Running costs are held flat over the years, so raise them if you expect them to climb.

A worked example

The starting figures are examples, not our prices. Take £600 a month of subscriptions that a build would replace, £100 a month of subscriptions you’d keep, a £15,000 build quote and £250 a month to run it, over five years.

In the expected case the bill rises 12.5% a year and the build carries a 12.5% contingency, so it costs £16,875. At the end of year one, renting has cost £7,200 and owning £21,075. By the end of year three it is £24,413 against £29,944, so renting is still ahead. Owning catches up in month 48, and by the end of year five it is £39,575 against £46,197 for renting.

The cautious case, with a 5% yearly rise and a 25% contingency, catches up in month 62, just after the five-year mark, so over five years renting is still slightly cheaper. In the best case, with a 20% rise and no contingency, owning catches up in month 40.

So the same figures give “own” over five years and “rent” over three. That is why the calculator asks how many years you want to compare, and why the decision depends on how long you expect the system to serve you.

What the sum leaves out

Some of the reasons for owning never show up in a cost comparison. A tool that makes your team work around its limits, data spread across ten vendors, and a feature you need sitting on someone else’s roadmap all cost money, but nobody can put a number on them for you. Businesses with several sites feel this most, because each branch drifts onto its own tools, and that is usually the case behind a multi-location platform. If any of them is the real reason you’re asking, note it beside the result.

Some reasons to keep renting don’t show up either. Nobody should build their own email delivery, video calls or payroll compliance, because the vendors’ scale buys reliability no single business could pay for. If a subscription does a generic job well, keep paying for it. Our comparison of renting software and owning the build goes through where each one wins, and custom software vs off-the-shelf covers the wider choice.

Frequently asked questions

Is custom software cheaper than SaaS?

Sometimes. The build costs more at the start and the subscription costs more each month, so the answer depends on how big the monthly gap is, how fast the bill grows and how many years you compare. A bill that grows with every seat or contact tends to favour owning over time. A small, flat bill usually favours renting.

How do I compare the cost of building software with buying it?

Add up everything you’d pay each way over the same period. For renting, that is the monthly bill, rising each year. For owning, it is the build, then hosting and upkeep, plus any subscriptions you’d still keep. Then find the month the running totals cross. The calculator above does this, and our guide on how to evaluate build vs buy covers the questions that aren’t about cost.

What if the build never catches up?

Then on cost alone, keep renting. That happens when the upkeep plus the subscriptions you’d keep come close to the bill you’d replace, or when the bill hardly rises. Owning might still make sense for one of the reasons the sum leaves out, but you would be paying for that.

Should I replace one subscription or the whole stack?

Start with the one whose bill hurts most or whose limits get in the way most often. Run that one through the calculator on its own, then try the wider stack. Tools that only connect other tools, like Zapier, are often the first to go, and our Zapier vs a custom integration comparison covers when that is worth doing.

Is my data stored?

No. The calculator runs in your browser and nothing you type is sent or saved. If you copy a link to share your figures, they sit after the # in the address, a part browsers never send to a website, so we never receive them.

Run it on your real stack

The calculator shows whether owning is worth a closer look. The closer look is your list of tools, what each one costs and which of them get in the way. Our custom software development work replaces the subscriptions worth replacing, and we will tell you which ones to keep paying for. We are Portsmouth software developers, working with firms across the UK.

Portrait of Alexander De Sousa, founder of Digital Royalty
Founder-led
“I’ve put everything I know into how this company works — the standards, the method, the care on every project. It runs through the whole team, and I hold us all to it.”

Alexander De Sousa · Founder LinkedIn

Featured on BBC Radio Solent

Get started

Tell us what you need

A few quick questions, then a straight answer from a real person — usually within a few hours.

What happens next

  1. 1 We reply A real person reads your answers and gets back to you, usually within a few hours.
  2. 2 Questions or a short call If anything isn't clear, we ask by email or book a short call. Before any call we audit your website and make the quick fixes it finds, free.
  3. 3 Your fixed quote A clear, fixed price in writing, within 48 hours of any call. There is no obligation to go ahead.

Tell us what you're working on

Whether it's a new site, a platform, or a process that shouldn't be manual any more — we'll tell you honestly if we can help.